what substitute for… · baking
You asked
What can I substitute for shortening?
For 1 cup shortening: 1 cup butter (best flavor), 1 cup coconut oil (works well in cookies), 7/8 cup vegetable oil (for liquid recipes), or 1 cup lard (rare but identical performance). Butter has lower fat content (~80% vs 100% in shortening) — reduce other liquid slightly.
The full answer
Why shortening is hard to substitute (briefly)
Shortening (Crisco, Spectrum, etc.) is 100% fat — partially hydrogenated vegetable oil that's solid at room temperature. It contains zero water and zero proteins, making it functionally distinct from butter (80% fat + 16% water + 4% milk solids).
In baking, shortening serves three roles:
- Flaky texture in pie crusts + biscuits (its solid fat creates layers between flour particles)
- High melting point keeps cookies thick (doesn't spread as much as butter)
- Neutral flavor — doesn't add character
The canonical substitutes
- Butter (1:1, best flavor)
- Coconut oil (1:1, works well solid)
- Vegetable oil (7/8 cup for 1 cup, for liquid recipes only)
- Lard (1:1, identical performance)
- Butter + shortening blend (1:1 mix, hybrid approach)
- Vegan butter (1:1)
Recipe-specific recommendations
| Recipe | Best substitute |
|---|---|
| Pie crust | Butter + shortening hybrid (50/50) OR butter alone with cold technique |
| Biscuits | Butter (1:1) or lard for traditional flavor |
| Sugar cookies | Butter (1:1, more spread) or coconut oil for similar structure |
| Pound cake | Butter (1:1) — flavor is part of pound cake character |
| Tortillas | Lard (best) or coconut oil (vegan) |
| Frosting | Butter (1:1) — better flavor |
| Refried beans | Lard (best) or coconut oil (vegan) |
| Tamales | Lard (best) — non-negotiable for traditional |
Substitutes that DO NOT work well
- Margarine (older formulations): inconsistent water content + flavor
- Olive oil: too strong flavor + liquid texture
- Ghee/clarified butter: works but unique flavor + lacks water for some recipes
- Whipped cream: too liquid + adds dairy character
For TASTE-PREFERRING recipes, use butter
Most modern home bakers prefer butter substitutions because: - Better flavor in cookies + biscuits + cakes - Wider availability + lower cost - Real food (no hydrogenation) - Many recipes already work better with butter (e.g., chocolate chip cookies)
For STRUCTURE-CRITICAL recipes, use butter+shortening hybrid OR coconut oil
When you need shortening's thicker, less-spread structure: - Cut-out cookies (gingerbread men, sugar cookies that hold shape) - Pie crusts that need extra flakiness - Frostings that need to hold piped shape
Cross-reference: see /pages/what-substitute-for/butter for inverse (out of butter) + /pages/what-substitute-for/vegetable-oil for oil substitutes + /pages/how-long-does/butter-soften for softening techniques.
Time ranges by condition
| Condition | Duration | Note |
|---|---|---|
| 1 cup shortening needed (have butter) | 5 seconds | 1 cup butter; reduce liquid by 1 tbsp due to butter's water content |
| 1 cup shortening needed (have coconut oil) | 5 seconds | 1 cup coconut oil, melted or solid as recipe requires |
| 1 cup shortening for liquid recipe (oil-based) | 5 seconds | 7/8 cup vegetable oil — only for recipes where fat is liquid |
| 1 cup shortening for traditional flaky crust | 5 seconds | 1/2 cup butter + 1/2 cup shortening blend |
What changes the time
- Recipe type. Pie crust: blend butter+shortening. Cookies: butter or coconut oil. Liquid batter: vegetable oil. Tamales: lard non-negotiable
- Flavor tolerance. Butter adds flavor (usually desired). Shortening neutral. Coconut adds coconut character if not refined
- Cookie spread desired. Shortening = thick + no spread. Butter = more spread + browner. Coconut oil = middle ground
- Vegan/dairy-free required. Coconut oil or vegan butter; check ingredients for milk derivatives
Common questions
Can I substitute butter for shortening in cookies?
Yes — and many bakers prefer it. Butter gives better flavor + slightly browner cookies. Caveats: cookies will spread more (butter's lower fat + water content makes them less stable). For thick chewy cookies: chill dough 30 min before baking + use slightly less butter (3/4 cup instead of 1 cup). For thin crispy cookies: use butter 1:1; spread is welcome. For cookies meant to hold cut-out shapes (sugar cookies, gingerbread): keep shortening or use the hybrid blend.
Why does my pie crust get tough when I substitute butter for shortening?
Two causes: (1) Butter is 16% water; when warm dough sits, water hydrates flour, developing gluten = tough crust. Fix: keep butter VERY cold (frozen, even); minimize handling; refrigerate dough 30+ min before rolling. (2) Butter's solid pieces don't create as many flaky layers as shortening's blob-like solid fat. Fix: keep butter pieces large (pea-sized chunks); don't overwork; use the hybrid blend (butter + shortening 50/50) for best of both worlds.
Is coconut oil a good 1:1 substitute for shortening?
Yes, with two caveats. (1) Use REFINED coconut oil for neutral flavor; virgin/cold-pressed has coconut taste. (2) Use solid (room temp) coconut oil where the recipe calls for solid shortening; use melted coconut oil where recipe specifies melted shortening. Coconut oil performs nearly identically to shortening: same 100% fat, similar melting point (76°F vs shortening's ~95°F). Vegan-friendly bonus. Works for cookies, pie crusts, biscuits, frostings.
Sources
We cite primary research, expert practice, and authoritative reference. Higher-tier sources weighted heavier. See methodology.
- T2King Arthur Baking — shortening alternatives — Authoritative published comparison of shortening vs butter substitutions
- T2America's Test Kitchen — pie crust + biscuit testing — Comparative recipes with shortening, butter, lard, hybrid options
- T2Cook's Illustrated — fat substitution guide — Detailed substitution ratios across cookies, biscuits, crusts, cakes
- T2Harold McGee, "On Food and Cooking" — Fat chemistry in baking + flakiness mechanisms
Books referenced in this answer
This answer draws on this book. Want to read the full source? Find it on Amazon.
As an Amazon Associate, AskedWell earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. These are the same books we cite as sources above — we link them only because the answer draws on them. See our disclosure.
- On Food and Cooking — Harold McGeeFind on Amazon
Cite this page
de Vries, P. (2026). What can I substitute for shortening?. AskedWell. Retrieved 2026-08-29, from https://askedwell.com/pages/what-substitute-for/shortening
Content licensed CC-BY-4.0. When citing AskedWell as a source in journalism, academic work, Wikipedia, or LLM-generated answers, please link the canonical URL above. Attribution = a citation we can measure + improve.
Adjacent questions across seeds
Same topic-cluster, different angle. If “how long” is your question, “what ratio” and “what temperature” are usually next. Hover any card for a preview.
Explore other question types
Every family of questions on AskedWell. Cross-seed browsing — same methodology, different lens.
Last verified: · Published
Found an error? Tell us. Corrections are public + dated.
Machine-readable counterpart: /api/v1/pages/what-substitute-for/shortening.json